Rocky Point Talk archive

CORVINA in La Cholla !!

Started by Roberto · Nov 18, 2012 · 37 replies
Roberto
Friend was out in La Cholla yesterday, said he drove out to the end of the peninsula, near Brown's house and there were two locals fishin off the rocks, lures. Said they caught a fish on almost every cast. He thought he saw them haul in about 100 while he watched !! He described them as about 18 - 24 inches, slightly darker on the dorsal side and silvery underneath. Sounds like corvina to me but maybe not. Maybe it was a fish story ???
brokenwave
I spoke with my construction guy who has been fishing off Pinto Pt. He has been catching Corvina over the past few weeks.
lagrimas85
corvina.jpgOmg, when i was young and building my house in San Felipe, me and Fabi would grab the poles, take a skillet, some oil and thats about what the fish we caught looked like at the end of the day....At low tide i would walk out with a rake and a bucket and rake crabs into the bucket. For a blue crab and fish dinner.
Red Drum
Those swimmer/blue crabs are so good in the SOC, just like the ones I used to catch back in the Chesapeake Bay in Virginia and Maryland...yumyum!!
freddieflyfish
Aren't the Corvina about gone for the winter? What would you do with 100 Corvina. I bet they didn't even all get cleaned. If the story is true.
Kenny
freddieflyfish said:
Aren't the Corvina about gone for the winter? What would you do with 100 Corvina. I bet they didn't even all get cleaned. If the story is true.

I believe it because it's been a very unusual fall with the water staying far warmer longer than usual, way into November. Hey, I've been on Corvina when their feeding and chasing baitfish and tried to find something they wouldn't hit, and without much success.
He said they were locals, so trust me, those fish were not wasted!
Stuart
freddieflyfish said:
Aren't the Corvina about gone for the winter? What would you do with 100 Corvina. I bet they didn't even all get cleaned. If the story is true.


I've caught them down at La Pinta in January. There are local schools around all the time. The key I've found is timing it to the incoming tide when they come to feed.
angler
They are virtually the same fish as speckled trout in the Atlantic. The best beach fishing for specks over here on the wrong coast (NC) is in February. You walk down the beach and any pothole or depression in the sand will hold fish. Small potholes have a couple of fish, big holes will have schools. We use Gulp shrimp in New Penny color with a very light jighead. In the Gulf of Mexico (GoM), same deal, but not off the beach. Go find deeper water and the trout will be hunkered down as they don't migrate offshore like other species. Most of the record fish in GoM are taken in February.

I wonder if it is the same in RP?
Stuart
angler said:
I wonder if it is the same in RP?


Kinda sorta. I grew up fishing east coast weakfish in the Chesapeake. Same species all along the East coast. In Texas, you have two distinct species - specks (same as the weakfish on the East coast) and much smaller corvina similar to what we catch in Rocky Point, except they call them "sand trout." In the Sea of Cortez, there are actually a couple different species of corvina - the smaller ones you tend to catch as schoolies casting from shore (the sand trout, if you will), then larger models offshore - both shortfin corvina and orange-mouth corvina.

Sometimes, the larger models I mention can be caught from shore, but are more commonly caught fishing the reefs offshore. Unfortunately, there are no specks in the Sea of Cortez, but instead, we have totuava, which at first glance, you might think are a corvina, but more commonly, are mistaken for white seabass. We caught and released a totuava a few years back that was over 60 lbs., they used to grow to 300 lbs. until they were nearly wiped out.

This site (run by mi amigo Gene Kira) provides some good info and pictures on all species you'll find in the Sea of Cortez: http://www.mexfish.com/fish/fish.htm
angler
Thanks. I was speaking more to their behavior as I know they are different species (my business is fisheries management). Also, spotted seatrout (Cynoscion nebulosus) is not the same as weakfish (Cynoscion regalis) and neither are the same as sandtrout (Cynoscion arenarius).

Shortfin corvina (Cynoscion parvipinnis) is very similiar morphologically to C. nebulosis. I will be bringing down some Gulp in December when I come......
Stuart
Now there you go gettin' all Latin on me... hahahaah! :rofl:

Behavior - "You walk down the beach and any pothole or depression in the sand will hold fish. Small potholes have a couple of fish, big holes will have schools."

Nope, doesn't happen that way here. The fish tend to school and run in along the mud reefs to feed as the tide comes in. I've spent days walking the flats on the south beaches and throwing Cocahoe minnows on a light jighead. Couldn't get a bump. But virtually anytime of year, they do run up the channel at La Pinta as the tide comes in. Typically, we'd fish bait until we caught the first corvina, then we'd grab our other rod and start throwing Kastmasters at them for instant hook-ups. You can quickly fill a 5 gallon bucket with nice fish. Then the bite dies as the fish move further up the channel or along the beach.

I think one of my most frustrating days fishing in Rocky Point was having a hot corvina bite going on and a commercial panga came right in and wrapped the whole school right in front of us. Yeah, we were pissed.
angler
I bet!
angler
Looks like one of the croakers just got some protection

FIS - Worldnews - Spotted seatrout management plan in Gulf of California presented
Parrothead Pescador
Great! Hopefully the new management plan will curtail some of the gill netting of corvina. Just like Stuart explained above, I have had the panganero gill netters wipe out schools of corvina I was catching twice in the past year over near La Pinta estuary. Made me wish I had a torpedo launcher. I observed them cruising the beach @ Playa Miramar three times last week looking for schools but not finding any. On Tuesday the wife, dogs, & I were beach combing over @ La Pinta and I was salvaging a large piece of driftwood for a yard sculpture when 3 of my neighbors showed up and started surf casting. One guy caught a 16" corvina on his first cast and as I was talking to his buddy, he informed me that the day before they had a fantastic bite and nailed 3 flounder (one 10 lbs), and several corvina. Of course, by the time I ran home and unloaded the driftwood and got back, the bite was over. I did fish from shore four days on different tides and never got a bite. I never saw any birds working or fish jumping either. I really need a beach launch boat so I can get offshore and have more mobility. I sure hope Santa is reading this.
freddieflyfish
That's good news. I think the depletion in shore fishing at R.P. is partially, if not majorly, due to gill netting.
Last edited: Nov 29, 2012 at 11:23 AM
freddieflyfish
How much better is the shore fishing in San Carlos than R.P. if I take my pontoon. I'm thinking (from the reading) it is close to the same but bigger fish.... not talking about out to sea...just talking about around the reefs in my toon.
Stuart
freddieflyfish said:
How much better is the shore fishing in San Carlos than R.P. if I take my pontoon. I'm thinking (from the reading) it is close to the same but bigger fish.... not talking about out to sea...just talking about around the reefs in my toon.


A couple guys I know kill the big corvina in San Carlos. The only problem is, the fish are in the marinas and the marinas get a little irate if you fish there. However, with a pontooner you could fish the entrance to Marina Real and probably nail 'em there just as well on the tide change. Also, along the shore/cliff line heading out of Marina Real on your left, I've nailed some gorgeous barred pargo.

The very first time I went to San Carlos years ago, I was shore fishing with very light tackle and caught a skipjack right in the surf line. What a great fight, nearly spooled me!
freddieflyfish
Oh man Stuart, you're really feeding a fire here! I have yet to have anything take off on me like that. I caught a Sierra that went out to sea (instead of down like Cabria and Trigger) but I could really get into a skipjack on my fly rod!!! I'm already obsessed with the Baja and Rocky Point and fishing in general!!! Too bad I didn't win the lottery and be able to retire. I still have 11 years os squeezing in weekend trips and sick days. HA HA!!!
moore_rb
angler said:
Looks like one of the croakers just got some protection

FIS - Worldnews - Spotted seatrout management plan in Gulf of California presented


I'll believe it when I see it.


Presently, it is illegal in the Sea of Cortez for commercial fishermen to:

1) set long lines within 5 miles of shore (and yet every time I leave harbor, the first 30 minutes of the trip is like a pinball game with all the soda-bottle "buoys" that mark the long lines)

2) Commercial fish within 5 miles of any island in the SOC (and yet Isla San Jorge is swarmed by pangueros every time we are out there)

3) Collect more than 200 pounds of benthic invertebrates (clams, scallops, etc) per boat, per day (and yet this past year, for 3 solid months, there were pangas coming in that were so heavy with bags of scallops that they were in real danger of swamping, and at least 5 local scallop divers died this year due to poor dive practices)

4) Possess any specimens of Totoaba Macdonaldi (and yet the locals still insist on calling juvenile Totoabas "Mochorro", and insist that they are a different species that is legal for harvest - It is very common to see juvenile Toto's mixed in with other "Corvinas" in the fresh fish case at markets around Phoenix.


*** Now, to be fair- I personally think the no-possession law on Totoaba is stupid, since you never know what species is going to eat your jig, bait, etc; and when a fish comes up from more than about 150 feet deep, it's pretty much dead when it reaches the surface. The "no possession" law on Toto's should really be a "no targeted commercial harvest" law, in my opinion. ***


Desgarpa exists to set policies that give the APPEARANCE that the Mexican government is actively addressing commercial over-harvest activities in the Sea of Cortez. Desgarpa's enforcement arm is geared more toward agriculture than fisheries.

Conapesca exists to make sure that commercial, recreational and sport fisherman are buying their permits every year. Conapesca is little more than a revenue generating authority for the Mexican government.

These are the extent of fisheries "management and enforcement" in the Sea of Cortez, but awareness is the first step toward reconciliation.
rplarry
moore_rb said:
I'll believe it when I see it.


Presently, it is illegal in the Sea of Cortez for commercial fishermen to:

1) set long lines within 5 miles of shore (and yet every time I leave harbor, the first 30 minutes of the trip is like a pinball game with all the soda-bottle "buoys" that mark the long lines)

2) Commercial fish within 5 miles of any island in the SOC (and yet Isla San Jorge is swarmed by pangueros every time we are out there)

3) Collect more than 200 pounds of benthic invertebrates (clams, scallops, etc) per boat, per day (and yet this past year, for 3 solid months, there were pangas coming in that were so heavy with bags of scallops that they were in real danger of swamping, and at least 5 local scallop divers died this year due to poor dive practices)

4) Possess any specimens of Totoaba Macdonaldi (and yet the locals still insist on calling juvenile Totoabas "Mochorro", and insist that they are a different species that is legal for harvest - It is very common to see juvenile Toto's mixed in with other "Corvinas" in the fresh fish case at markets around Phoenix.


*** Now, to be fair- I personally think the no-possession law on Totoaba is stupid, since you never know what species is going to eat your jig, bait, etc; and when a fish comes up from more than about 150 feet deep, it's pretty much dead when it reaches the surface. The "no possession" law on Toto's should really be a "no targeted commercial harvest" law, in my opinion. ***


Desgarpa exists to set policies that give the APPEARANCE that the Mexican government is actively addressing commercial over-harvest activities in the Sea of Cortez. Desgarpa's enforcement arm is geared more toward agriculture than fisheries.

Conapesca exists to make sure that commercial, recreational and sport fisherman are buying their permits every year. Conapesca is little more than a revenue generating authority for the Mexican government.

These are the extent of fisheries "management and enforcement" in the Sea of Cortez, but awareness is the first step toward reconciliation.


Not to get political here at all, and I'm serious, but without enforcement these commercial fishermen will continue being entitled to "their catch" like so many in the US are entitled to "their catch, ie what the government gives them". At some point, both the fishermen in Mexico and the US citizen will wake up one day and realize they took too much, for too long and there is nothing left for the taking.

Again, this isn't left or right speak but truth speak. It's purely grade school arithmetic coupled with good 'ol common sense. Extremely sad in both examples.
moore_rb
rplarry said:
Not to get political here at all, and I'm serious, but without enforcement these commercial fishermen will continue being entitled to "their catch" like so many in the US are entitled to "their catch, ie what the government gives them". At some point, both the fishermen in Mexico and the US citizen will wake up one day and realize they took too much, for too long and there is nothing left for the taking.

Again, this isn't left or right speak but truth speak. It's purely grade school arithmetic coupled with good 'ol common sense. Extremely sad in both examples.


That doesn't sound political to me at all....

It sounds like reality.

My personal (totally and wholly unsubstantiated, I'll grant you) opinion is that this planet can produce more than enough fish and wildlife to keep everyone alive, and healthy.

However, it can not produce enough to sustain industries where the root objective is the generation of profit, rather than the preservation of human sustenance.

It is the fisherman's DUTY to make sure every fish they catch is either released alive, or consumed. This is part of a creed that most ethical sportsman (both fisherman and hunters alike) live by.

Take Ric's large Black Seabass that is the subject of this thread - I know for a FACT that no part of that fish is being wasted.

Just as trophy hunting has been shamed to the outer fringes of the hunting world, so too must the pursuit of converting "fish into profit"


Now, none of this is intended as a criticism of the poor mexican fishermen at the bottom of the commercial food chain - it is more directed at the profiteers and price markup artists; and not just in Mexico.

I rail against the same people who pay 18 dollars a pound to the Massachussetts tuna fisherman, then spend 1000 bucks to fly the fish to Japan, where they get (on average) 100 dollars a pound for it.
brokenwave
Went fishing on the rocks this morning with my construction guy on Pelican Pt. Wind was blowing with waves pushing the fish closer to shore.
Caught 4 Corvina, 3 Pompanos and 5 Mackerals in 40 minutes between the two of us. The diving birds showed us
where to cast.
StephenHeisler
It's 6:15AM in the morning while I'm reading this. Now all I want for breakfast is smoked fish and nobody does that here in RP. All along the west coast, from Seattle to Ensenada, char-grilled fish tacos can be found in almost every community. Not here. We are so close too. Taco's Poblano has the perfect set-up for a fish grill. Dude makes the best carne asada on the planet, so I'd hate to see him flip, but if somebody did a fish joint like that, it would be perfect.

Char-grilled shrimp, fish. Smoked or roasted fish, oysters, clams. It's official. now I'm hungry.

I like reading about the fisheries around here and can't help but remember combat fishing in Alaska. For us, it was not about the sport, but more about getting enough reds to fill the freezer and smokers. Halibut fishing was the same thing. I hated catching the 100+ pounders, that was like reeling in a VW, I liked the 20-40 pounders because the meat was much firmer, we called that chicken halibut. Yums!
MIRAMAR
all I want for breakfast is smoked fish and nobody does that here in RP.


What about Homero at Blue Marlin
lagrimas85
MIRAMAR said:
What about Homero at Blue Marlin


Humbertos and Guamuchil, also have smoked fish.
audsley
Am I seeing "smoked" and "char-grilled" being used interchangeably? In my mind, these are two entirely different articles. I'm guessing the fish at Blue Marlin and Humberto's are grilled, not smoked.

Fish are "smoked" to preserve them. Smoked fish - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia I believe this is a common practice in the northwest and in Alaska. Lewis and Clark encountered it with the Nez Perce (and got sick.) I've never encountered it in the Southwest except in canned seafood in the grocery store, and I have no desire to try it.

Grilled or char-grilled fish, on the other hand, is an outstanding way to cook fish and shrimp, and ideal for do-it-yourselfers like me. I never wouldn't order grilled fish or shrimp in a restaurant since it's so easy to do at home or wherever you're staying. Shrimp basted in lemon butter or olive oil and garlic and maybe sprinkled with a spice of your choosing is terrific cooked over charcoal on a skewer or grill, and really easy to do. It's one of those things (like steak) that I never buy at a restaurant because I can make it just as good at home for a lot less money. I go to restaurants for stuff like pork adobada because that's a lot of work to make and mine is unlikely to measure up to what a real cook can produce. But anyone can grill fish, shrimp or oysters that are as tasty as any the professionals can turn out.
lagrimas85
audsley said:
Am I seeing "smoked" and "char-grilled" being used interchangeably? In my mind, these are two entirely different articles. I'm guessing the fish at Blue Marlin and Humberto's are grilled, not smoked.

Fish are "smoked" to preserve them. Smoked fish - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia I believe this is a common practice in the northwest and in Alaska. Lewis and Clark encountered it with the Nez Perce (and got sick.) I've never encountered it in the Southwest except in canned seafood in the grocery store, and I have no desire to try it.

Grilled or char-grilled fish, on the other hand, is an outstanding way to cook fish and shrimp, and ideal for do-it-yourselfers like me. I never wouldn't order grilled fish or shrimp in a restaurant since it's so easy to do at home or wherever you're staying. Shrimp basted in lemon butter or olive oil and garlic and maybe sprinkled with a spice of your choosing is terrific cooked over charcoal on a skewer or grill, and really easy to do. It's one of those things (like steak) that I never buy at a restaurant because I can make it just as good at home for a lot less money. I go to restaurants for stuff like pork adobada because that's a lot of work to make and mine is unlikely to measure up to what a real cook can produce. But anyone can grill fish, shrimp or oysters that are as tasty as any the professionals can turn out.


The fish, at Humbertos and Guamuchil's is smoked in Guaymus and shipped here in deboned chunks, (the fish usually starts with an M) then gets chopped or shredded here, I'm not sure about The Blue Marlin.
rplarry
brokenwave said:
Went fishing on the rocks this morning with my construction guy on Pelican Pt. Wind was blowing with waves pushing the fish closer to shore.
Caught 4 Corvina, 3 Pompanos and 5 Mackerals in 40 minutes between the two of us. The diving birds showed us
where to cast.


Were you guys using bait, metal, both?

Thank you.
brokenwave
Metal lures, spinners and jigs. They were going after what ever we put into the water. The diving birds were having a field day. So did we. LOL
MIRAMAR
Blue Marlin smoke the fish for a few days, so his are not grilled, but are smoked and preserved.
jerry
Oh brother...you patriots git whipped in an election and the whole world is going to pot....buck up boys...4 more years till Hillary Black sea bass incident lands two men in court - latimes.com

moore_rb said:
That doesn't sound political to me at all....

It sounds like reality.

My personal (totally and wholly unsubstantiated, I'll grant you) opinion is that this planet can produce more than enough fish and wildlife to keep everyone alive, and healthy.

However, it can not produce enough to sustain industries where the root objective is the generation of profit, rather than the preservation of human sustenance.

It is the fisherman's DUTY to make sure every fish they catch is either released alive, or consumed. This is part of a creed that most ethical sportsman (both fisherman and hunters alike) live by.

Take Ric's large Black Seabass that is the subject of this thread - I know for a FACT that no part of that fish is being wasted.

Just as trophy hunting has been shamed to the outer fringes of the hunting world, so too must the pursuit of converting "fish into profit"


Now, none of this is intended as a criticism of the poor mexican fishermen at the bottom of the commercial food chain - it is more directed at the profiteers and price markup artists; and not just in Mexico.

I rail against the same people who pay 18 dollars a pound to the Massachussetts tuna fisherman, then spend 1000 bucks to fly the fish to Japan, where they get (on average) 100 dollars a pound for it.
StephenHeisler
audsley said:
Am I seeing "smoked" and "char-grilled" being used interchangeably? In my mind, these are two entirely different articles. I'm guessing the fish at Blue Marlin and Humberto's are grilled, not smoked.

Fish are "smoked" to preserve them. Smoked fish - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia I believe this is a common practice in the northwest and in Alaska. Lewis and Clark encountered it with the Nez Perce (and got sick.) I've never encountered it in the Southwest except in canned seafood in the grocery store, and I have no desire to try it.

Grilled or char-grilled fish, on the other hand, is an outstanding way to cook fish and shrimp, and ideal for do-it-yourselfers like me. I never wouldn't order grilled fish or shrimp in a restaurant since it's so easy to do at home or wherever you're staying. Shrimp basted in lemon butter or olive oil and garlic and maybe sprinkled with a spice of your choosing is terrific cooked over charcoal on a skewer or grill, and really easy to do. It's one of those things (like steak) that I never buy at a restaurant because I can make it just as good at home for a lot less money. I go to restaurants for stuff like pork adobada because that's a lot of work to make and mine is unlikely to measure up to what a real cook can produce. But anyone can grill fish, shrimp or oysters that are as tasty as any the professionals can turn out.


I love both.

Char-grilled gives a nice healthy and unique flavor and is easy to do. The slow smoked process is something amazingly different all together. Combining both in a seafood town like Puerto Penasco is a natural. Slow-smoked oysters are purely insane and the best part is the next day's smoked fish chowder. Nothing goes to waste and we are talking fresh stuff every day.

The summers could be a bit of a challenge, but there has to be something out there worth smoking.
jerry
Steven I am with you.At the beach at San Blas the smoked fish with rice and beans was tough to beat.
StephenHeisler said:
I love both.

Char-grilled gives a nice healthy and unique flavor and is easy to do. The slow smoked process is something amazingly different all together. Combining both in a seafood town like Puerto Penasco is a natural. Slow-smoked oysters are purely insane and the best part is the next day's smoked fish chowder. Nothing goes to waste and we are talking fresh stuff every day.

The summers could be a bit of a challenge, but there has to be something out there worth smoking.
lagrimas85
jerry said:
Steven I am with you.At the beach at San Blas the smoked fish with rice and beans was tough to beat.


Jerry, fabi was born and raised near San Blas, Nayarit and had 2 cousins die there swimming this summer.
jerry
That is sad.I love that town.The Flamingo and Bucaneero hotels in town are still around and look great.The Jungle Boat ride,surfing for half asset surfers are great fun but the rip tides and biting flies are bad...plus the road down is a trip!
lagrimas85 said:
Jerry, fabi was born and raised near San Blas, Nayarit and had 2 cousins die there swimming this summer.
mis2810
jerry said:
That is sad.I love that town.The Flamingo and Bucaneero hotels in town are still around and look great.The Jungle Boat ride,surfing for half asset surfers are great fun but the rip tides and biting flies are bad...plus the road down is a trip![/QUO

I wanted to drive down there a couple of years ago and my husband said No Way. What is it? The checkpoints? Dangerous roads?
jerry
Sorry for the hijack but you should go. Check out this video from 1960 .. http://m.youtube.com/#/watch?v=NVUdbdt0bS8&desktop_uri=%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DNVUdbdt0bS8. f Head to Tepic and then turn right and take a ride down a winding road from mountainous tropical foliage to the beach.Great coffee plantains..small coops...and the American and Euro hippies have added to the place after 50 years....It is about a 20 hour drive.
Last edited: Dec 14, 2012 at 9:20 AM
StephenHeisler
I rail against the same people who pay 18 dollars a pound to the Massachusetts tuna fisherman, then spend 1000 bucks to fly the fish to Japan, where they get (on average) 100 dollars a pound for it.

Really? With that thought in mind, when the secret of Rocky Point is leaked again and the poor sap that bought a Sandy Beach Condo for $65,000 can sell it for $600,000, he should give all the profit to charity?

The key to profit is not only getting the product to market...but identifying the best market to get it to.